top of page

NOW BOOKING 
CATERING 2025

TEEJAY’S SWEET TOOTH

Changing the Way You Do Ice Cream

Home of Indy’s ONLY donut and Fruity Pebble Treat ice cream sandwich!!

Home: Welcome

MENU

Specialty Items

IMG_4610.jpg

DONUT ICE CREAM SANDWICH

Warm, glazed donut with 2 scoops and 1 topping

$7.50

FRUITY PEBBLE TREAT

Rice Krisipie's

"technicolor cousin"

$7.50

IMG_6902_edited.jpg
IMG_5107.jpg

MILKSHAKES

Create your own milkshakes

Starting at $ 7.95

Staff Favorites Include:

Oreo Shake (pictured with edible rim)

Fruity Pebble Explosion

Strawberry Shortcake

Death By Chocolate

Nutella Strawberry

COTTON CANDY BURRITO

Ice cream and toppings wrapped in cotton candy

$13.20

IMG_2088.jpg
Home: Products

MENU CONTINUED

SCOOPS

Served in cup or cone:
Kiddie $3.95
Single $4.55
Double $6.55
Flight (4 different flavors) $10.00

SUNDAES

Served with Chocolate & Caramel drizzle, Whipped Cream, Nuts, & Cherry


Kiddie $5.65

Single $6.25

Double $8.25

HOT FUDGE SUNDAES

Single $6.25

Double $9.00

OTHER SPECIALTIES

Warm Donut Sundae $8.50

Warm Brownie Sundae $9.00

Warm Chocolate Chip Cookie Sundae $9.00

Soda Floats $7.25

Strawberry Shortcake Sundae $7.70

Sorbet Slushee $7.45

Cloud Cone $7.00

Cloud Shake $8.50

Waffle Sundae $10

Cotton Candy Burrito $13.20

Also Available

HAND-PACKED

Pints $8.50 & Quarts $15.75

(Order Ahead Available)

Home: Products
IMG_8271.JPG

HOW IT WORKS

1. Pick a menu item

2. Choose a flavor

3. Add a topping

4. Enjoy!

All of our items are custom made, meaning YOU CHOOSE what you want to do!

We can do most things, if we cannot, we will let you know.

Note: If you show us a picture we cannot always identify the ice cream used, remember that was probably someone's personal creation.

Home: Store Policies
IMG_8266.JPG

ABOUT

Donuts and the BEST Locally Sourced Ice Cream? Yes, you heard that right! Serving sixteen, rotating flavors served between a warm, glazed donut or Fruity Pebble Treat. Sounds a bit much? Don't worry, we also serve it more traditionally, such as by the scoop or in a sundae. Established in 2018, owners Taylor and Jerome are both licensed dental hygienists, satisfying one sweet tooth at a time. Call it job security.

Flavors change regularly, you can see an updated list of flavors on our Facebook and Instagram Stories daily.

We also have a few specialty Milkshakes; Cookie Butter Explosion, Cookie Monster Mash, and Fruity Pebble Explosion- head to Instagram or Facebook to see pictures. 


Toppings include: Cinnamon Toast Crunch, Oreo, Fruity Pebbles, Cap 'N Crunch, Cheesecake Bites, Cookie Dough, Brownie Bites, M&M's, Cocoa Puffs, Reese's Puffs, Chopped Reese's, Rainbow Sprinkles, Chocolate Chips, Lucky Charms, Trix, Graham Cracker, Nilla Wafers.

**Vegan and Gluten-Free Options Available

Home: About
Home: Features

LET'S PARTY!

PACK N' GO

Pre-packaged with lids; orders of 50+

Single $4.20/each

Double $6.20/each

**Available for pick up for delivery but not responsible for storage

SUNDAE BAR

Create your own Sundae Bar with your choice of 4 flavors of ice cream and sundae toppings - Whipped Cream, Cherry, Nuts, Chocolate and Caramel Sauces.

$7/guest

**Additional charges may apply

Image by Adi Goldstein
Home: Services

GIFT CARDS

Gift cards are available all year round. To purchase, stop by to pick up a traditional gift card or CLICK HERE to purchase a digital gift card.

Home: HTML Embed

HOURS OF OPERATION

Come visit us inside
or swing by our drive-thru window
(Located on the East end of the building)

FALL/WINTER HOURS

Monday & Tuesday CLOSED
Wednesday - Thursday 5pm-9pm
Friday - Saturday 3pm-9pm
Sunday 3pm-8pm

Untitled.jpg
Home: Opening Hours

APPLY FOR A JOB

WE WANT YOU!

We are looking to add to our AMAZING team. 
Applicants must have open availability/flexible schedule.
Customer service experience is a plus.
(Part-time only)

Thanks for submitting!

Image by Brendan Church
Home: Join the Team

CONTACT

For Information Regarding:
Catering for weddings, open houses, office events, etc.
Fundraisers, employment opportunities, & other inquiries
Please Contact Us

8660 Purdue Rd Suite 600, Indianapolis, IN 46268, USA

(317) 744-9764

  • Facebook
  • Google Places

Thanks for submitting!

Home: Contact
bottom of page